Don’t Miss Your Chance to Hear Gazan Author Yousef Aljamal Oct 1 at PSU
AFSC is sponsoring a west coast book tour for Yousef Aljamal and Light in Gaza: Writings Born of Fire and there are two Portland events in the schedule! Portland Jewish Voice for Peace is a co-sponsor of these events along with Quaker Palestine Israel Network...JVP MOURNS BRUTAL ISRAELI ATTACKS ON GAZA AND NABLUS The Nakba is not just a historical event, but an ongoing structure of violence and ethnic cleansing. New York, NY (May 9 2023)—We are grieving and enraged by the Israeli government’s assault on Palestinians in Gaza...
Purim After Hawara
by Peter Beinart. March 2023 I wanted to talk about the events in the West Bank about a week after what happened at [the village of] Huwara. And what I want to suggest is that understanding that event in context requires us to recognize that what we...JVP National Statement on Jenin Killings
THE ISRAELI GOVERNMENT IS INCITING A NEW PHASE OF VIOLENCE 27 JANUARY 2023 PRESS RELEASE/STATEMENT As the tally of lives lost in Palestine and Israel continues to grow, it becomes increasingly clear that the Israeli government has launched a new phase of state...
Latest on Facebook
2,131
Jewish Voice for Peace - Portland, OR
For more information, please visit our website at http://www.jvpportland.org/. JVP opposes anti-Jewis
Young Palestinian prisoners describe harsh treatment in Israeli jails
wapo.st
Teenager Noah Bseso says he was held in solitary confinement and given little more than bread some days, part of a crackdown in Israeli jails after Oct. 7.Ceasefire reveals the toll of devastation in Khan Younis
www.972mag.com
Palestinians are using the lull in fighting to stock up on supplies and check on their homes and families throughout Gaza. For many, it’s terrible news.
www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2023-12-02/ty-article/.premium/the-hero-in-the-jerusalem-shooti...![]()
![]()
Yuval Doron Kestelman, a brave citizen who rushed to the scene of a terror attack in Jerusalem on Thursday and killed the terrorists, was shot and killed by soldiers who arrived on the scene after him.![]()
![]()
Errors can happen at the scene of such incidents, such as in cases of friendly fire or mistaken identity. But this is not what happened there. Kestelman threw down his pistol and raised his arms, opening his jacket to show that he was not carrying an explosive device. He begged for his life and was shot anyway, when it was clear that he posed no danger.![]()
![]()
- Advertisment -![]()
![]()
Kestelman’s tragic death stems from the fact that the person who shot him was convinced that he was an Arab terrorist. But the real reason is the conception that a terrorist deserves to die and cannot emerge alive from an incident.![]()
![]()
U.S. threatens to stop supplying guns after Ben-Gvir gives them out at political events![]()
Stop the Ben-Gvir gun show![]()
From victim to victimizer: Why some E. J'lem Arabs feel drawn to October 7 conspiracies![]()
This is an approach that has been promoted by politicians for years, even before the case of the soldier Elor Azaria, who shot an incapacitated terrorist in Hebron, and even more so after that incident. This notion is furthered by a campaign that also includes influencers and people in the media on the right side of the political spectrum.![]()
![]()
Israel At War: Get a daily summary direct to your inbox![]()
Email *![]()
![]()
Please enter a valid email address![]()
Sign Up![]()
There is occasional criticism of soldiers or policemen who have killed terrorists at the scene of an attack but did not “confirm the kill.” In many cases, when a terrorist is killed, no one investigates whether using lethal fire was necessary, and the shooter receives the public’s backing for being a hero.![]()
![]()
The link between this campaign and the policy of wholesale distribution of firearms initiated by National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir has brought anarchy and the Wild West to Israel. In the incident in Jerusalem, the mistake was made by soldiers, but there is no doubt that the continued distribution of weapons will lead to further mistakes in the future. Civilians who intervene in security incidents could be suspected of being terrorists and shot dead.![]()
![]()
The criminal investigation that must take place regarding those involved in this incident (which the police tried to evade with the troublesome argument that this was a case of firing by both sides) is only the first step for drawing lessons from Kestelman’s death.![]()
![]()
The first lesson must be the total cessation of the campaign and policy that call for not allowing any terrorist to emerge alive from any terror attack. This shouldn’t be a mere nod and wink, but a return to enforcing the rule of law and the rules of engagement, which forbid shooting at anyone who no longer poses a risk.![]()
![]()
These rules have always been more than ethical or juridical ones; they were meant precisely to prevent incidents such as the one that took place on Thursday. You don’t kill a person who is no longer dangerous, even if the shooter is convinced that the person is a terrorist. Soldiers, police officers and armed civilians do not comprise a punitive and executive body carrying out capital punishment.![]()
![]()
Opening fire at the scene of an incident is a means of eliminating a danger, not a punitive measure. It was only a matter of time before a tragedy like what happened to Kestelman took place. The blame is not just on the shooter, but on everyone who encouraged him to do what he did.